java - Cannot use comparable with father-son-grandson inheritance

Question

Given the following code :

public abstract class Participant {
    private String fullName;

    public Participant(String newFullName) {
        this.fullName = new String(newFullName);
    }

    // some more code 
}


public class Player extends Participant implements Comparable <Player> {    
    private int scoredGoals;

    public Player(String newFullName, int scored) {
        super(newFullName);
        this.scoredGoals = scored;
    }

    public int compareTo (Player otherPlayer) {
        Integer _scoredGoals = new Integer(this.scoredGoals);
        return _scoredGoals.compareTo(otherPlayer.getPlayerGoals());
    }

    // more irrelevant code 
}

public class Goalkeeper extends Player implements Comparable <Goalkeeper> { 
    private int missedGoals;        

    public Goalkeeper(String newFullName) {
        super(newFullName,0);
        missedGoals = 0;
    }

    public int compareTo (Goalkeeper otherGoalkeeper) {
        Integer _missedGoals = new Integer(this.missedGoals);
        return _missedGoals.compareTo(otherGoalkeeper.getMissedGoals());
    }

    // more code 
}

The problem is that Goalkeeper won't complie.

When I try to compile that code the Eclipse throws:

The interface Comparable cannot be implemented more than once with 
different arguments: Comparable<Player> and Comparable<Goalkeeper>

I'm not trying to compare with Player, but with Goalkeeper, and only with him.

What am I doing wrong ?

Answer 1

The problem is described in Angelika Langer's Generics FAQ #401:

Can a class implement different instantiations of the same generic interface?

No, a type must not directly or indirectly derive from two different instantiations of the same generic interface.

The reason for this restriction is the translation by type erasure. After type erasure the different instantiations of the same generic interface collapse to the same raw type. At runtime there is no distinction between the different instantiations any longer.

(I highly recommend checking out the whole description of the problem: it's more interesting than what I've quoted.)

In order to work around this restriction, you can try the following:

public class Player<E extends Player> extends Participant implements Comparable<E> {
    // ...
    public int compareTo(E otherPlayer) {
        Integer _scoredGoals = this.scoredGoals;
        return _scoredGoals.compareTo(otherPlayer.getPlayerGoals());
    }
    // ...
}


public class Goalkeeper extends Player<Goalkeeper> {
    // ...
    @Override
    public int compareTo(Goalkeeper otherGoalkeeper) {
        Integer _missedGoals = this.missedGoals;
        return _missedGoals.compareTo(otherGoalkeeper.getMissedGoals());
    }
    // ...
}