java - Use the serialVersionUID or suppress warnings?

Question

I want to create a class that, for example, extends HttpServlet? My compiler warns me that my class should have a serialVersionUID. If I know that this object will never be serialized, should I define it or add an annotation to suppress those warnings?

What would you do and why?

Answer 1

I don't know Java best practices, but it occurs to me that if you are claiming that serialization will never happen, you could add a writeObject method which throws. Then suppress the warning, safe in the knowledge that it cannot possibly apply to you.

Otherwise someone might in future serialize your object through the parent class, and end up with a default serialized form where:

• the form isn't compatible between different versions of your code.
• you've suppressed the warning that this is the case.

Adding an ID sounds like a bodge, since what you really want to do is not serialize. Expecting callers not to serialize your object means that you expect them to "know" when their HttpServlet is of your class. That breach of polymorphism is on your head for having a Serializable object which must not be serialized, and the least you can do is make sure unwary callers know about it.